Nursing Home Deficiencies and Fines Update

The non-profit ProPublica.com has released data related to nursing home abuse and the nursing homes that are the reported as having the most deficiencies. The data comes from the US Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, but ProPublica allows users to search by keyword, city, as well as the nursing home’s name. They also allow users to search “across all of the reports at once.”[1] 

The database covers over 118,000 deficiencies within nursing homes while covering approximately 14,565 homes across the United States. Their search engine looks through the “narrative” section of inspection reports (where inspectors describe the conditions in the nursing homes and any deficiencies that have been discovered). They are studying the details that are being overlooked elsewhere.

Homes with Most Serious Deficiencies 

Ohio

Scioto Pointe

740 CANONBY PLACE, COLUMBUS, OH 43223

Scioto Pointe is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Columbus, Ohio.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation and are owned by Longterm Lodging, Inc. They have a two out of five-star rating from CMS and have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies at seven of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 40 deficiencies, two of which involve the failure to protect residents from the spread of infection.

The Laurels of Hilliard

download.jpeg

5471 SCIOTO DARBY ROAD, HILLIARD, OH 43026

The Laurels of Hilliard is a medium-sized nursing facility that accepts Medicare and Medicaid. While Eadie Hill Trial Lawyers does not currently have an open case against the Laurels of Hilliard, they do have cases against the Laurels at Athens and the Laurels at Mt. Vernon, all owned by the same for-profit parent company. They have a two out of five-star rating from CMS and have been cited by ProPublica.com as a nursing home with five  serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 52 deficiencies, two of which involve the failure to protect residents from the spread of infection. There is also a report of at least one COVID-19 related case at this facility.

Rolling Hills Rehab and Care Center

download.jpeg

68222 COMMERCIAL DRIVE, BRIDGEPORT, OH 43912

Rolling Hills is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Bridgeport, Ohio.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have a one out of five-star rating from CMS and have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies at five of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 97 deficiencies.

Eliza Bryant Center

7201 WADE PARK, CLEVELAND, OH 44103

Eliza Bryant Center is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Cleveland, Ohio.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have a one out of five-star rating from CMS and have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies at five of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 30 deficiencies.

Beaver Creek Health and Rehab

3854 PARK OVERLOOKE DRIVE, BEAVER CREEK, OH 45431

The Beaver Creek Health and Rehab is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Beaver Creek, Ohio.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have a one out of five-star rating from CMS and have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies with four of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 67 deficiencies.

Wapakoneta Manor

1010 LINCOLN AVE, WAPAKONETA, OH 45895

The Wapakoneta Manor is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Wapakoneta, Ohio.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have a five out of five-star rating from CMS but they have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies with four of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 13 deficiencies.

Whetstone Gardens and Care Center

3710 OLENTANGY RIVER ROAD, COLUMBUS, OH 43214

The Whetstone Gardens and Care Center is a medium/large-sized nursing home facility in Columbus, Ohio.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have a one out of five-star rating from CMS and they have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies with four of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 39 deficiencies. One of which has been an infection-related deficiency. This facility has also been noted as having at least one case of COVID-19.

Geriatric Center of Mansfield

50 BLYMYER AVENUE, MANSFIELD, OH 44903

The Geriatric Center of Mansfield is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Mansfield, Ohio.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a non-profit corporation. They have a one out of five-star rating from CMS and they have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies with four of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 32 deficiencies. Two of which have been infection-related deficiencies.

Ridgewood Manor

3231 MANLEY ROAD, MAUMEE, OH 43537

Ridgewood Manor is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Maumee, Ohio.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have a two out of five-star rating from CMS and they have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies with four of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 35 deficiencies. One of which have been an infection-related deficiency. This facility has also been noted as having at least one case of COVID-19.

Pennsylvania

The Gardens at West Shore

70 POPLAR CHURCH ROAD, CAMP HILL, PA 17011

The Gardens at West Shore is a large-sized nursing home facility in Camp Hill, Pennsylvania.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have become a special focus home because of so many issues from CMS and they have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies with four of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 143 deficiencies, six of which have been infection-related deficiencies. This facility has also been noted as having at least one case of COVID-19.

The Grove at Greenville

110 FREDONIA ROAD, GREENVILLE, PA 16125

The Grove at Greenville is a medium/large-sized nursing home facility in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been rated one out of five stars by CMS and they have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies with three of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 32 deficiencies, one of which have been infection-related deficiencies.

Cathedral Village

600 EAST CATHEDRAL ROAD, PHILADELPHIA, PA 19128

Cathedral Village is a medium/large-sized nursing home facility in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a non-profit corporation. They have been rated two out of five stars by CMS and they have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies with three of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 42 deficiencies, one of which have been infection-related deficiencies. This facility has also been noted as having at least one case of COVID-19.

Corner View Nursing and Rehabilitation Center

6655 FRANKSTOWN AVENUE, PITTSBURGH, PA 15206

Corner View Nursing and Rehabilitation Center is a medium/large-sized nursing home facility in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been rated a special focus facility by CMS and they have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies with three of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 71 deficiencies, three of which have been infection-related deficiencies.

Cheltenham Nursing and Rehab Center

600 W CHELTENHAM AVENUE, PHILADELPHIA, PA 19126 

Cheltenham Nursing and Rehab Center is a large-sized nursing home facility in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been rated a special focus facility by CMS and they have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies with five of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for41 deficiencies, one of which was an infection-related deficiency. This facility has also been noted as having at least one case of COVID-19.

West Virginia

Valley Center

1000 LINCOLN DRIVE, SOUTH CHARLESTON, WV 25309

Valley Center is a medium-sized nursing home facility in South Charleston, West Virginia.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been rated two stars out of five by CMS and they have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies with five of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 53 deficiencies, two of which were infection-related deficiencies.

Morgantown Health and Rehabilitation Center

1379 VAN VOORHIS RD, MORGANTOWN, WV 26505

Morgantown Health and Rehabilitation Center is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Morgantown, West Virginia.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit limited liability corporation. They have been rated one star out of five by CMS and they have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies with five of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 40 deficiencies, two of which were infection-related deficiencies.

Brightwood Center

840 LEE ROAD, FOLLANSBEE, WV 26037

Brightwood Center is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Follansbee, West Virginia.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been rated one star out of five by CMS and they have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies with three of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 57 deficiencies, two of which were infection-related deficiencies.

Riverside Health and Rehabilitation Center

6500 MACCORKLE AVENUE SW, SAINT ALBANS, WV 25177

Riverside Health and Rehabilitation Center is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Saint Albans, West Virginia.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit limited liability corporation. They have been rated one star out of five by CMS and they have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest amount of serious deficiencies with three of the most serious deficiencies. It has been cited for 48deficiencies, three of which were infection-related deficiencies. This facility has also been noted as having at least one case of COVID-19.

Homes with Most Fines  

Ohio

Rolling Hills Rehab and Care Center

68222 COMMERCIAL DRIVE, BRIDGEPORT, OH 43912

Rolling Hills is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Bridgeport, Ohio.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a non-profit partnership. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $233k.

Holzer Senior Care

380 COLONIAL DRIVE, BIDWELL, OH 45614

Holzer Senior Care Center is a small-sized nursing home facility in Columbus, Ohio. They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a non-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $239k.

Isabelle Ridgeway Post Acute Care Center LLC

1520 HAWTHORNE AVENUE, COLUMBUS, OH 43203

Isabelle Ridgeway Post Acute Care Center LLC is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Columbus, Ohio. They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $183k.

Wayside Farm Inc.

4557 QUICK RD, PENINSULA, OH 44264

Scioto Pointe is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Columbus, Ohio. They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $192k.

Scioto Pointe

740 CANONBY PLACE, COLUMBUS, OH 43223

Scioto Pointe is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Columbus, Ohio. They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $166k.

Oak Pavilion Nursing Center

510 OAK STREET, CINCINNATI, OH 45219

Oak Pavilion Nursing Center is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Cincinnati, Ohio. They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $154k.

Pennsylvania

St Francis Center for Rehabilitation and Healthcare

1412 LANSDOWNE AVENUE, DARBY, PA 19023

St. Francis Center for Rehabilitation and Healthcare is a large-sized nursing home facility in Latrobe, Pennsylvania. They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit partnership. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $449k.

Loyalhanna Care Center

535 MCFARLAND ROAD, LATROBE, PA 15650

Loyalhana is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Latrobe, Pennsylvania. They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit partnership. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $374k.

The Gardens at Blue Ridge

3625 NORTH PROGRESS AVE, HARRISBURG, PA 17110

The Gardens at Blue Ridge is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Harrisburg Pennsylvania. They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $272k.

Inglis House

Inglis House is a large-sized nursing home facility in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $263k.

Twin Lakes Rehabilitation Center

 227 SAND HILL ROAD, GREENSBURG, PA 15601

Twin Lakes Rehabilitation Center is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Greensburg, Pennsylvania. They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $240k.

Suburban Woods Health and Rehab

2751 DEKALB PIKE, NORRISTOWN, PA 19401

Suburban Woods Health and Rehab is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Norristown, Pennsylvania. They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $232k.

Frey Village

1020 NORTH UNION STREET, MIDDLETOWN, PA 17057

Frey Village is a medium-sized nursing home facility in North Huntingdon, Pennsylvania. They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a non-profit church related business. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $217k.

Transitions Healthcare North Huntingdon

8850 BARNES LAKE ROAD, NORTH HUNTINGDON, PA 15642

Transitions Healthcare North Huntingdon is a medium-sized nursing home facility in North Huntingdon, Pennsylvania. They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $213k.

Manorcare Health Services-Pottsville

420 PULASKI DRIVE, POTTSVILLE, PA 17901

Manorcare Health Services- Pottsville is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $210k.

Willow Terrace

ONE PENN BOULEVARD, PHILADELPHIA, PA 19144

Willow Terrace is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $203k.

West Virginia

Trinity Healthcare of Logan

Photo Credit: Trinity Healthcare Services Website

1000 WEST PARK AVENUE, LOGAN, WV 25601

Pierpont Center at Fairmont Campus is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Fairmont, West Virginia.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $354k.

Pierpont Center at Fairmont Campus

1543 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD, FAIRMONT, WV 26554

Pierpont Center at Fairmont Campus is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Fairmont, West Virginia.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $354k.

Morgantown Health and Rehabilitation Center

1379 VAN VOORHIS RD, MORGANTOWN, WV 26505

Morgantown Health and Rehabilitation Center is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Morgantown, West Virginia.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $308k.

Maples Nursing Home

1600 BLAND STREET, BLUEFIELD, WV 24701

Maples Nursing Home is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Bluefield, West Virginia.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $223k.

Willow Tree Healthcare Center

1263 SOUTH GEORGE STREET, CHARLES TOWN, WV 25414

Willow Tree Healthcare Center is a medium-sized nursing home facility in Charles Town, West Virginia.  They participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs.  They are a for-profit corporation. They have been cited by ProPublica.com as one of the nursing home with the highest number of fines, totaling $212k.

Ohio Facilities That Have Been the Most Cited

  1. That Ohio Department of Health inspects nursing homes and can cite them for violations of nursing conduct
  2. Anyone can file a complaint against a nursing home. Link to the form on our webpage:  https://www.eadiehill.com/nursing-home/file-ohio-nursing-home-complaint-abuse-neglect/
  3. Here is a list of the most cited facilities in Ohio:
Nursing Home NameCitySerious DeficienciesFinesPayment SuspensionsTotal Deficiencies
Isabelle Ridgway Post Acute Care Campus LlcColumbus2$203,4361114
Fairlawn Rehab And Nursing CenterAkron4$142,973297
Rolling Hills Rehab And Care CtrBridgeport5$309,862192
Arbors At MariettaMarietta1$198,94991
Logan Care And RehabilitationLogan2$11,42790
Columbus Colony Elderly CareWesterville0$44,364282
Englewood Health And RehabEnglewood0$6,50082
Crystal Care Of Coal GroveCoal Grove0$22,09579
Winchester Care & RehabilitationCanal Winchester179
Newark Care And RehabilitationNewark0$146,297178
Carriage Inn Of Cadiz IncCadiz2$77,03774
Woodview Care And RehabilitationColumbus0$1,406273
Arbors At MilfordMilford1$20,12772
Dixon Healthcare CenterWintersville0$9,42571
Premier Estates Of Norwood TowersCincinnati071
Summit’s Trace Healthcare CenterColumbus1$7,15071
Blue Ash Care CenterCincinnati0169
Astoria Place Of CincinnatiCincinnati0$17,88269
Buckeye Terrace Rehabilitation And Nursing CenterWesterville068
Eaglewood Care CenterSpringfield2$369,611267
Liberty Retirement Community Of Lima IncLima1$16,12066
University Manor Health & RehaCleveland0$12,04166
Crystal Care Center Of Franklin FurnaceFranklin Furnace0166
Heartland Of MariettaMarietta065
Uptown Westerville HealthcareWesterville1$81,36464
Hudson Elms Nursing HomeHudson364
Manor At Whitehall TheWhitehall0$139,59964
Addison Heights Health And Rehabilitation CenterMaumee0$10,00064
Country Club Retirement Ctr IvBellaire1$228,06663
Larchwood Village Retirement CommunityCleveland063
Premier Estates Of Cincinnati-RiversideCincinnati2$132,644162
Echo Manor Extended Care CtrPickerington061
Glenwood Care And RehabilitationCanton1$11,700260
Pickerington Care And RehabilitationPickerington360

[1] https://www.propublica.org/article/how-to-search-nursing-home-inspect

Do you have questions about a possible abuse, neglect, stroke, or heart attack case? Contact us now using this confidential form. Or leave a comment below--but remember the comments are public, not confidential.

 Our No Fear Guarantee 

You’ve probably seen the lawyer ads: “No Fee Guarantee!” “No Fees if We Don’t Win!”   

Guess what? That’s true for just about any plaintiff’s lawyer.  It’s what a “contingency fee” means.  It doesn’t mean they’ll work hard.  Or get a good result for you.  It doesn’t mean much at all.

What we promise you is a NO FEAR guarantee.

What does that mean?  For 99% of our clients, a medical injury caused by negligence is new.  The medical malpractice lawsuit process is new.  Depositions, discovery, trial . . . everything is new.

New can be scary.  Especially when it involves having to testify under oath.

We’ve developed systems that let you address and move past the fear. Through education and information about the process. Role-playing and other preparation techniques. We empower you to be fearless.  Because this process is hard enough.

Contact us now.

Get the Definitive Guide . . . FREE

Get the definitive guide on Nursing Home and Assisted Living Claims — a $14.99 value — yours free, without commitment.

I don’t want the guide

Nursing Home and Assisted Living Wrongful Death Claims Book Cover three dimensional with shadow